doodlehause1.jpg

Social Media 101: A better blog than book from Brogan

Great blogs don’t always translate into great books. Chris Brogan’s latest book, Social Media 101, proves this out.

’101′ is a collection of several posts that originally appeared at www.chrisbrogan.com. Knowing that much of the content would be familiar to me, I picked the book up for in-flight reading, with modest expectations. It wanted to revisit some well-organized, thought-provoking Brogan posts for a few hours. And, upon arrival pass the book along to someone inexperienced in social media. I was disappointed on both accounts.

Sadly, the 320-page book is poorly organized.  It’s not a book that is easily read from beginning to end.  It lacks expected depth, vision and context.  It feels like a collection of abandoned conversations among distracted participants. The book is unsatisfying for social media enthusiasts. And, it’s too disorganized for newbies.

Books culled from blogs should provide readers with forethought and organization that isn’t possible from typical ’publish-as-you-go’ blogging.  ’101′ doesn’t do that. Topics aren’t bundled, broadened, or bridged enough to be engaging.

I like Chris Brogan. And, I like his blog — but not in this format. I prefer the content in its raw, online format.

Too Much?

Chris Brogan has been in high demand since publishing Trust Agents.  He is active and prolific. Here’s one theory (courtesy of Hubspot) about how he gets it all done:

Further Reading:

About Troy Janisch

Troy Janisch, Publisher of Social Meteor, is a digital marketing professional and social media beatnik. He is a contributor to SmartBrief on Social Media. Troy leads the marketing team at Sentry Insurance, but don’t let that scare you. He rarely talks about insurance in mixed company [grin]. Like a good social media program, SocialMeteor.com is all about content. It’s not a consulting company or marketing agency.

  • http://www.chrisbrogan.com Chris Brogan…

    I’m with you. I don’t like how it ended up, organization-wise. I think it’s a bit too flowy. There’s a method to how I put it together, but because I’m a lot closer to the material, it is visible to me, but not to others. You’re right. It’s not as big a hit as I’d wish.

  • Iyas AlQasem

    I liked the book. I agree for sure on the organisation (there were also a few parts which should have been closer together and were a little repetitive, e.g. discussion on Linked-in), but there were enough gems in there to compensate for that. Actually just looking through the footnotes is interesting in itself (which makes sense, as they would have been hyperlinks on the blog).

    All in all, could have been restructured into a shorter and better flowing book, but much of the content was useful for sure.

  • http://www.wendysoucie.com Wendy Soucie

    First let me say that Chris Brogan’s blog/email newsletters are about the only one I let into my email anymore. I think – no I know – he is one of the pillars who helped me get started.

    But as far as the book is concerned (which I haven’t read yet) why not an editor. Isn’t that what editors are for? Take the great content and help bring it into good form? I know there are some top writers, editors and publishers who could have helped (many who need the work too). Chris Brogan by now should understand DIY efforts well enough to know exactly when you hire a professional to get it right. I hope he didn’t use that new software that promises to create a book from your blog posts!

    Wendy
    Xeesm.com/wendysoucie

  • http://tmaperitus.com Tom Marks

    I haven’t read the book, yet. But I commend Chris on his response. Rather than being defensive, he was honest. Rather than taking exception, his comments were exceptional. Others can learn from Chris on how to respond to criticism.

  • http://collinkromke.com Collin Kromke

    I’m a huge Chris Brogan fan, and echo Wendy’s comments above about his blog/email newsletters. I read great content from Chris nearly every day, and really enjoyed his book Trust Agents.

    I haven’t read Social Media 101 yet, but it’s on my wish list. Maybe I can get Troy to lend me his copy?